Study shows how news shapes humanitarian aid from governments

Published by  News Archive

On 14th Dec 2021

A view of the tents at a relief camp set up for those made homeless after an earthquake
Getty Images

A new study involving the University of East Anglia shows that media coverage of crises can increase governments’ allocation of emergency humanitarian aid — whether or not the crisis merits it.

This is because intense, national news coverage triggers other accountability institutions - the public, civil society, elected officials - who put pressure on governments to announce additional funding.

Dr Martin Scott at UEA, Dr Mel Bunce at City, University of London, and Dr Kate Wright  from the University of Edinburgh, interviewed 30 senior policymakers in 16 of the world’s largest democratic, humanitarian donors. In 2020, these donor countries were collectively responsible for over 90 per cent of all humanitarian funding.

The researchers found that news coverage only appeared to influence emergency humanitarian aid budgets. These relatively small, emergency budgets are kept in reserve to respond to rapidly deteriorating, or sudden-onset crises.

According to their interviewees, governments’ annual humanitarian aid allocations – which are much larger – are unaffected by news coverage.

However, the researchers found that a lack of news coverage did influence policy-making about annual aid allocations.

This was because policymakers assumed that other governments were much more influenced by news than they were. So, they tried to compensate for what they assumed would be less funding for these ‘forgotten crises’.

Dr Scott, of UEA's School of International Development, said: “For government departments seeking to resist such media influence, and defend their needs-based decision-making, they should consider building stronger public, and ministerial, understanding of humanitarian principles.”

Dr Wright added: “These findings have important implications for government donors, news organisations and aid agencies, and for wider understanding of how news coverage may influence foreign policy.”

“If you wanted to influence donors via the news media, this research suggests you should target national news outlets, rather than international or local ones. You should also target countries that put more resource into untagged emergency aid, rather than annual aid allocations. And look at countries where there are career-oriented foreign ministers running aid agencies that have limited independence,” explained Dr Bunce.

'The Influence of News Coverage on Humanitarian Aid: The Bureaucrats’ Perspective' is published in the journal Journalism Studies. 

Latest News

 
08 Jun 2023

UEA Dance Squad complete 12-hour charity dance-a-thon in support of teammate’s chronic health condition

The University of East Anglia's Dance Squad held a 12-hour dance-a-thon in May, to support the Crohn’s and Colitis UK charity and in solidary with squad member...

Read more >
 
Top 25 graphic in pink, UEA Broad in background
07 Jun 2023

UEA climbs into UK’s top 25 in Complete University Guide 2024

The University of East Anglia (UEA) has risen into the UK’s top 25 universities, up to joint 22nd, in a leading league table released today (Wednesday 7 June).

Read more >
 
A woman looking at two fizzy drink bottles in a supermarket.
05 Jun 2023

Banning multibuy discounts drives sales rather than curbing appetites

With the government under pressure to devise policies that help curb excessive consumption of unhealthy foods and drinks, new research from the University of...

Read more >
 
An older woman drives a car with a passenger.
06 Jun 2023

Researchers and driving assessors join forces to support drivers with dementia

Researchers at the University of East Anglia are part of a new project to improve driving assessments for people with dementia.

Read more >
Are you searching for something?
 
An older woman drives a car with a passenger.
06 Jun 2023

Researchers and driving assessors join forces to support drivers with dementia

Researchers at the University of East Anglia are part of a new project to improve driving assessments for people with dementia.

Read more >
 
L-R: A computer screen with coding; the UEA logo and TenderFlow logo
01 Jun 2023

UEA to introduce new AI programme based on Google’s open-source hardware-accelerated JavaScript library

Students from the University of East Anglia (UEA) will be among the first in the country to be taught skills in artificial intelligence based on TensorFlow.js,...

Read more >
 
UEA campus
01 Jun 2023

UEA rises into world’s top 40 sustainable universities

UEA has climbed into the top 40 universities in the world for sustainability according to the Times Higher Education Impact Rankings, the first and only global...

Read more >
 
A woman receiving treatment for diabetes.
31 May 2023

The breakthrough that could lead to new obesity treatments

Researchers at the University of East Anglia and the University of Cambridge have made an important discovery in the race to find treatments for obesity and...

Read more >
 
Charterhouse Warren, taken in 1972-1973.
30 May 2023

4,000-year-old plague DNA found – the oldest cases to date in Britain

A researcher from the University of East Anglia has helped find the oldest case of the plague in Britain.

Read more >
 
Chemistry diagram titled: Facilitating surface functionalisation and biological applicability
01 Jun 2023

UEA researchers develop a synthetic strategy to protect and functionalise inorganic nanoparticles, enhancing their theranostic potential

Researchers at UEA, led by Dr María J. Marín, have worked in collaboration with the group of Dr Thomas Hirsch at the University of Regensburg to develop a...

Read more >