Report calls for Indigenous Peoples’ knowledge to be included in climate policy

Published by  News archive

On 29th Sep 2022

An indigenous man stands in front of a camera.
Joel Redman / If Not Us Then Who

A new report highlights how recognising Indigenous Peoples’ and local communities’ knowledge systems could do more to address climate change than many current approaches.
It also argues for ensuring the full and equitable inclusion of Indigenous Peoples and local communities within policy processes.

The report, published as a white paper, was produced by an international team of 12 authors led by Prof Ben Orlove at Columbia University in the US, and including Dr Neil Dawson from the University of East Anglia (UEA) in the UK, and Dr Victoria Reyes-García from the Catalan Institution for Research and Advanced Studies (ICREA) and Institute of Environmental Sciences and Technology of the Autonomous University of Barcelona (ICTA-UAB), in Spain. The team also included five Indigenous scholars.

Co-sponsored by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), and the International Council on Monuments and Sites, the paper was a response to growing calls for international attention to be given to culture in climate change science and policy.

It is often assumed that climate change responses must involve new technology or behavioural changes driven by governments and big companies. However, the authors draw on diverse literature and case studies to illustrate why recognition of Indigenous Peoples’ and local communities’ knowledge systems would add much to western scientific approaches and represent a needed transformative change from current top-down efforts.

This knowledge, held by the world’s 400 million Indigenous Peoples, plus many local, traditional communities, brings alternative ways of understanding and proven, bottom-up ways of addressing complex global problems, such as climate change and biodiversity loss.

However, counterproductively, many of these communities continue to suffer social, political, and economic discrimination - often including violence and displacement from their territories - and are most affected by environmental and climate change.

Dr Dawson, research fellow at UEA’s School of International Development and one of the report’s lead authors, said: “Respecting the human rights of Indigenous Peoples, their territories and their knowledge could do far more to address climate change than many proposed solutions.
“It's shocking that this would represent such a huge change, but this report shows that diverse worldviews need much more recognition in climate politics and science."

The examples detailed in the report include the contribution of Mapuche spirituality to climate change mitigation in Chile, customary processes guiding coastal village relocation in Fiji, local water management knowledge in the Spanish Sierra Nevada, and Indigenous fire management practices for forest conservation in Bolivia.

It also examines the resilience associated with traditional stone walling for agriculture in the Cordillera Region of the Philippines, local flood risk management in informal settlements in Sierra Leone, and Indigenous knowledge in urban settings, such as the San Francisco Bay area and Phoenix Valley in the United States.

Enhanced collaboration between western science and these diverse knowledge systems has been increasingly called for in international reports, as a way to improve the effectiveness of climate action.

“Put simply, many international bodies now recommend far more prominent roles and opportunities for Indigenous leaders and representatives to influence decisions and commitments in global climate negotiations and national level climate strategies,” said Dr Reyes-García, ICREA Professor at ICTA-UAB.

“But, as the report illustrates, this is not so quick and easy to achieve. Knowledge systems are highly complex, rooted in differing worldviews and values. Although sometimes assumed to be outdated and not relevant to the modern world, Indigenous knowledge systems are active, dynamic, contemporary, and highly resilient.”

Knowledge systems not only include values, such as spiritual beliefs and connections to nature, but also ways of deciding, organising and actively governing, managing and caring for land and resources.

They play a crucial role in sustainably managing much of the world’s critical ecosystems, species and resources.

“There is a growing consensus that we are not responding to climate change with the necessary speed or effectiveness,” explained Rosario Carmona, research fellow at the Research Centre for integrated Disaster Risk Management in Chile.

“To meet this challenge, we urgently need to understand the problem from a different perspective. Indigenous Peoples' values and worldviews have much to contribute.”

The report – titled ‘Intangible cultural heritage, diverse knowledge systems and climate change’ - outlines steps to be taken towards enhanced recognition of Indigenous and local knowledge systems, such as full, secure rights to Indigenous territories and languages, respect for rights, and highlights characteristics of more equitable collaboration.

Developing intercultural understanding, trust and appropriate governance processes can take years and goes against many assumptions and entrenched ways of addressing environmental crises, but the report says this is essential for sustaining ecosystems and people.

At local levels more effective climate action could be achieved through securing rights to Indigenous territories and supporting customary institutions. National climate strategies and Nationally Determined Contributions should include customary governance and local stewardship as vehicles for delivering sustainable emissions levels.

At an international level, the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change should elevate the role of the Local Communities and Indigenous Peoples Platform and facilitate more direct resourcing of Indigenous Peoples and local communities to support the application and resilience of diverse knowledge systems.

In addition, the assessment processes of the IPCC should include more Indigenous scholars as assessment authors/lead authors, use wider forms of citation and case studies for the upcoming Assessment Round 7 and beyond, and more evidence synthesis related to the roles played Indigenous Peoples and local communities through their traditional but evolving systems.

Latest News

A male nurse slumped against a wall.
06 Dec 2022

Care home nurses still need support to recover from Covid trauma, research shows

Those on the front line of the Covid pandemic need mental health support to help them recover from, or manage, the stress and trauma they faced - according to...

Read more >
Peter Hemmins with robot
01 Nov 2022

Productivity East hosts Robot Wars

Productivity East is usually home to UEA’s engineering students, but on 5 November it played host to almost 100 robots and their creators in the RobotWars...

Read more >
image of the brain
01 Dec 2022

University study to support families after Traumatic Brain Injury 

UEA is one of four universities to receive £140,000 funding to conduct a study to determine whether storytelling can support the wellbeing and adjustment of...

Read more >
Hanna Thomas Uose
30 Nov 2022

UEA creative writing student wins national writers prize for unpublished novel

Hanna Thomas Uose, who is studying for an MA in Prose Fiction at the University, has won the Morley Prize for Unpublished Writers of Colour 2022. 

Read more >
Are you searching for something?
Hanna Thomas Uose
30 Nov 2022

UEA creative writing student wins national writers prize for unpublished novel

Hanna Thomas Uose, who is studying for an MA in Prose Fiction at the University, has won the Morley Prize for Unpublished Writers of Colour 2022. 

Read more >
An overweight woman in a doctor's office.
30 Nov 2022

Overweight women most likely to suffer long Covid

Overweight women are more likely to experience symptoms of long Covid according to new research from the University of East Anglia.

Read more >
Two panels of the climate change mural artwork
25 Nov 2022

Climate change mural now on display at Norwich City Hall in historic year for Climatic Research Unit

On the 50th anniversary year of UEA’s Climatic Research Unit (CRU), the stark impact of climate change has been brought into focus by a giant mural now on...

Read more >
HSJ Awards logo
05 Dec 2022

UEA’s contribution to Clinical Associate in Psychology training shortlisted for national award

UEA, alongside the University of Plymouth and partners, has been shortlisted for two awards at the 2023 Health Service Journal (HSJ) Partnership Awards.

Read more >
Chemical molecules
01 Nov 2022

UEA researchers uncover how ancient protein-bound iron cofactors are assembled in bacteria

Mass spectrometric studies of the assembly of an essential and common iron- and sulfur-containing cofactor has revealed a ‘sulfur first’ mechanism.

Read more >
01 Nov 2022

Dec 22 issue of UEA Chemistry Magazine is out now

The December 2022 edition of our UEA Chemistry Magazine: yoUr chEm mAg is now available.

Read more >