New study finds ‘paedophile hunter’ groups violate human rights, must be regulated

Published by  News Archive

On 18th Jun 2020

judge hammer

The methods used by so-called ‘paedophile hunter’ groups need to be subjected to more rigorous official oversight, according to new research from the University of East Anglia (UEA).

Vigilante citizen groups around the UK have organised in recent years to launch covert operations to entrap people they suspect of trying to commit child sexual offences, often filming the moment a suspect arrives at an arranged encounter. These groups usually report the alleged crime to police, but often post video footage of the confrontation on social media channels, sometimes livestreaming it in real time.

The activities of these groups, which have sometimes involved the use of violence against alleged suspects, are antithetical to numerous core values and functions of the criminal justice system, said Dr Joe Purshouse, a lecturer in criminal law in the UEA’s School of Law. His findings are published today in the Journal of Law and Society.

This research comes ahead of a UK Supreme Court judgment next month, which will determine whether or not the tactics of ‘paedophile hunter’ groups, and the use of their evidence by police, infringe on the privacy rights of their targets.

Dr Purshouse, whose research focuses on the intersection of human rights law, policing and technology, said: “It should not be permissible for procedural safeguards and human rights laws, which constrain police investigations, to be bypassed by groups of citizens who decide for themselves to engage in intrusive surveillance, public censure and shaming exercises.

“English law is failing to adequately regulate the activities of paedophile hunters. In fact, this research found that more investigatory discretion is afforded to paedophile hunters than to state law enforcement agencies.

“Untrained paedophile hunters are able to bypass procedural safeguards and regulations on police investigations, and undermine due process and violate the fundamental human rights of suspects.

“Moreover, the tactics these groups use are incompatible with the rules of criminal evidence and procedure, and may damage the proper administration of justice. In short, their activities may jeopardise potential criminal proceedings and lead to failed prosecutions of potentially dangerous offenders.”

As private citizens, paedophile hunters’ activities fall outside the scope of guidelines that law enforcement must comply with when carrying out undercover sting operations. However, they depend on the police and prosecution service to bring offenders to justice.

Typically the groups use intrusive investigative methods, posing as children on social media platforms and chatrooms to lure potential child sex offenders into ostensible illicit encounters. The paedophile hunters then confront the alleged suspect at an arranged meeting while filming and sometimes uploading the encounter straight online.

In addition to cases of mistaken identity and smearing innocent people, these arranged assemblies have led to immediate and sustained social media attacks on the alleged perpetrators and their family members. The footage is often circulated widely and left open for comments before a court (if a case goes that far) can restrict publication to safeguard the defendant’s right to a hearing in front of an impartial jury.

Police have acknowledged they are overwhelmed by a significant rise in online child sex offences, and paedophile hunters’ evidence has been used in numerous successful prosecutions for child grooming offences, including cases involving repeat offenders.  

But, Dr Purshouse said, “If paedophile hunters are perceived by the public to be ‘doing something’ about child sexual abuse, there is a danger that policy makers and practitioners may take too placatory a stance toward these groups. Police have been known to give advice to these groups and some senior police figures have suggested that police could collaborate with hunter groups.

“Furthermore, poor investigatory practices by paedophile hunters might have the effect of unduly diverting criminal justices resources. Their contributions to police investigations may be more hindrance than help.”

While the police and Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) may sometimes act on evidence gathered by paedophile hunter groups, “the courts should not allow paedophile hunters to operate outside the constraints of police-led covert investigations,” Dr Purshouse said.

“In these circumstances, the state becomes the partner in a joint undercover policing enterprise. To keep accepting evidence provided by these groups and turn a blind eye to how the evidence is gathered is to signal tacit approval of these activities and implicitly induce them.

“The criminal justice system exists to remediate and deter criminal wrongdoing, and these functions are not served when criminal conduct is manufactured. To the extent that courts ‘play their part’ by affording paedophile hunters investigatory leeway to engage in precisely this manufacturing of criminality, they undermine their own integrity.

“It is the responsibility of the state to administer punishments for those who have committed crimes, and not individual citizens.”

‘Paedophile Hunters’, Criminal Procedure and Fundamental Human Rights is published in the Journal of Law and Society on 18 June 2020.

Study law at UEA

More world-leading research

Latest News

Subtropical Atlantic Forest, Southern Brazil
15 Sep 2020

Study reveals impact of centuries of human activity in American tropics

The devastating effects of human activity on wildlife in the American tropics over the last 500 years are revealed in a new study published today.

Read more >
Soldiers in a savannah
14 Sep 2020

Study examines how civil wars affect wildlife populations

A new study comprehensively reveals how civil wars impact wildlife in countries affected by conflict.

Read more >
Union Jack and EU flag on cracked wall background

Amending Brexit deal will increase frictions within UK and beyond

The government’s decision to scrap part of its Brexit deal will increase frictions with the EU, as well as threatening the fragile political equilibrium in...

Read more >
Are you searching for something?
testing for coronavirus in a lab
07 Sep 2020

Testing Initiative at UEA

UEA intends to offer coronavirus testing to all students and staff working on campus at the start of term.

Read more >
04 Sep 2020

UEA lecturer makes Newton Prize shortlist

A University of East Anglia (UEA) Honorary Senior Lecturer, Sue Down, is part of a team that has been shortlisted for the 2020 Newton Prize. 

Read more >
Researcher with gloved hand holding vial containing HIV blood sample, with more samples in the background
27 Aug 2020

The patients left behind by HIV research

People with HIV from BAME communities, women and heterosexual men are underrepresented in HIV studies – according to new research from UEA and Western Sydney...

Read more >
Man viewing online healthcare app on smartphone screen
03 Sep 2020

New app to forecast life expectancy

Read more >
Elderly woman's hands sorting pills into a pill organiser
02 Sep 2020

Stopping ‘risky’ medicines for older people in hospital

Read more >
Foods containing vitamin C
27 Aug 2020

How Vitamin C could help over 50s retain muscle mass

Vitamin C could be the key to better muscles in later life – according to new research from UEA.

Read more >