Changes needed to prevent controversial pharmaceutical deals

Published by  News Archive

On 22nd May 2020

pharmaceutical drugs

New research from the University of East Anglia (UEA) recommends changes to the system which sees drug companies strike deals with competitors to stop them producing cheaper generic alternatives.

These ‘pay-for-delay’ deals involve a payment from a branded drug manufacturer to a generic maker in order to delay market entry. In return for withdrawing its challenge, the generic firm receives a payment and/or a license authorizing it to enter the market at a later date, but before the expiration of the patent itself.

Such deals may block entry by other generic firms and have been challenged by competition authorities in Europe and the US on grounds of being anticompetitive. They can cost consumers and health systems millions by delaying the introduction of cheaper generic drugs for several years.

Dr Farasat Bokhari, Dr Franco Mariuzzo and Dr Arnold Polanski, of UEA’s School of Economics and Centre for Competition Policy, developed a model of generic entry and patent litigation to show that the branded firm can pay off the first generic challenger and then ward off entry by second or later challengers by threatening to launch an authorized generic via the first paid-off challenger. The model captures the essential features of market entry rules for drugs and the patent litigation in both Europe and the US.

Compared to the current first-filer system in the US, where generic exclusivity is awarded to the first generic applicant, the researchers endorse a switch to a system that instead rewards the first successful challenger, which they say will result in fewer pay-for-delay deals.

Publishing their findings today in the Journal of Economics & Management Strategy, they also recommend preventing a branded firm from launching a pseudo or authorized generic against an independent generic that wins patent litigation, as this will prevent pay-for-delay deals for weak patents.

They advise that competition authorities should be cautious about using payment to a generic firm as a workable surrogate to measure the strength of a patent. This is because the payment depends on other factors as well, and therefore low payment does not necessarily mean that the underlying patent is strong and no harm has been caused to the consumers by the pay-for-delay deal.

Dr Bokhari said: “While pay-for-delay deals may be beneficial to some extent, in that they might save courts and administrative bodies, such as patent offices, time and effort, they allow branded drug firms to charge monopoly prices and in a typical deal there may be several years delay in a cheaper version becoming available.

“Investigation and fines can be important in deterring such deals. However, the more important policy question is what can be done to prevent such entry limiting agreements in the first place?

“One also has to ask why such deals are stable in the first place. If a branded firm pays the generic firm to stay out of the market and they accept the deal, what stops the next generic drug maker knocking on the branded firm’s door, looking for a similar payoff? And if they do, how much do they have to pay and how can the original deal be profitable?

“The late generic challengers can be credibly threatened that even if they succeed in invalidating the patent and enter, the branded firm will launch the authorized generic prior to their entry and will capture large portion of generic profits. Therefore, it is important that the branded firms’ ability to launch authorized generics be legislatively limited.”

Previous studies have found that a pay-for-delay deal can cost as much $3.5 billion per year to US consumers - with prices dropping by as much as 75% after generic entry - and can slow a generic entry to the market by up to five years.

‘Entry limiting agreements: first mover advantage, authorized generics and pay-for-delay deals’, Farasat A.S. Bokhari, Franco Mariuzzo, Arnold Polanski, is published in the Journal of Economics & Management Strategy on May 22, 2020.

Study economics at UEA

More world-leading research

Latest News

  News
Photo of Professor Sue Fairweather-Tait
29 Oct 2020

UEA professor appointed Chair of new health claims committee

A nutrition expert from UEA has been appointed as Chair of Public Health England’s new national committee helping to protect the public from misleading food...

Read more >
  News
Senior hands giving small planet earth model to a child
28 Oct 2020

20 years of pioneering climate research

From adapting to heatwaves, to decarbonisation and coastal sea-level rises, the work of the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research assesses and explores...

Read more >
  News
Complex roundabout and road network in the UK
29 Oct 2020

Why people with dementia go missing

People with dementia are more likely to go missing in areas where road networks are dense, complicated and disordered – according to new research from the...

Read more >
Are you searching for something?
  News
The White House in Washington DC
27 Oct 2020

Decision 2020: UEA experts on next week’s US presidential election

UEA experts in American politics, courts, society, history and international relations are providing analysis and context around the approaching US presidential...

Read more >
  News
Person peeling an 'I voted' sticker from a strip with USA flag in the background
23 Oct 2020

Join UEA students & experts as the US election unfolds

Political experts and students from the University of East Anglia (UEA) will join universities from across the world in an online debate of the US presidential...

Read more >
  News
Ziggurats on UEA campus
22 Oct 2020

Force of nature: UEA campus wins Green Flag Award for fourth straight year

In a year when making the most of the great outdoors has been more important than ever, UEA’s campus has won a Green Flag Award for the high quality of its...

Read more >
  News
Aurora logo
21 Oct 2020

Aurora Network turns four and introduces Student Champion Scheme

UEA’s students will get the chance to make their voice heard on a continental stage as a Student Champion, as the Aurora Network celebrates its fourth anniversary.

Read more >
  News
Minoo waterfall in autumn, Minoo Park, Osaka, Japan
21 Oct 2020

Improving access to and awareness of parks are key to a more equitable Japan

Increasing the awareness of and access to green space could create more health equality across socioeconomic groups in Japan, according to new research from the...

Read more >
  News
Diatoms
21 Oct 2020

New project aims to provide genetic insights into key aquatic microbes

Scientists at the University of East Anglia (UEA) are to embark on the largest algal genome sequencing project to date.

Read more >
  News
Image of a student handing over a food package
20 Oct 2020

Volunteering linked to improved life satisfaction, happiness, and quality of life

Research revealing how volunteering can increase wellbeing, and how charities can avoid volunteer burnout as they plan their response to the effects of the...

Read more >