The UEA Law School at Earlham Hall

How to turn your passion into a PhD and then get that published

By Jennifer Young

Many years ago, when the world was quieter, cooler, and less terrifying, I worked in the television industry, specialising in comedy programming. It was the days when television had money and nobody wanted to defund the BBC.

My role worked on the new-fangled cable television channels, and over the years I held various editorial roles before setting up my own television compliance consultancy. The “compliance” part reflects the requirement that Radio and TV Channels in the UK must hold a licence to broadcast by the regulator (OFCOM) and agree that their programme output will comply with the law and OFCOM’S broadcasting regulations. If they do not, the channel loses their licence to broadcast.

My area of expertise was comedy and live broadcasting. Programme producers sent me scripts and rough-cuts (the early stages of a programme). Sometimes the content could be considered obscene and offensive, and my job was to weigh up the content and its context and judge these against the regulations and (presumed) audience sensitivities and expectations. I would have to advise the producer if the content might be so obscene, or offensive to the point that it crossed the nebulous “red lines” and would potentially breach the broadcast regulations. It was fun but also had a serious side. For example, if writers had used stereotypical characters or discriminatory language it was important to ensure the language was not targeting a vulnerable group but rather illustrating the abhorrent nature of the language (context).

I am intrigued not only by how broadcast regulations are interpreted but also the subjective nature of editorial decisions. This led me back to education and to the University of East Anglia. I undertook a master’s degree in Media Law, Policy and Practice at the UEA. At the same time, I saw an exhibition at the V&A celebrating the 50th anniversary of the Theatres Act 1968. This Act abolished the state censorship of the theatre. Up until 1968 stage plays had to be approved by the Lord Chamberlain’s office prior to being performed in licensed theatres. The exhibition displayed examples of what the Lord Chamberlain, or his colleagues, had cut or rejected in the plays submitted to them. What interested me the most was that political satire was banned and the way in which the various laws and rules meant it was nigh on impossible to discuss any political events, the royalty, or politicians on the public stage.

Having sworn never to stay in academia, this exhibition led me to embark on a PhD exploring the regulation of political entertainment. My PhD was funded by the South and East Network for Social Sciences. This body pays a stipend and the tuition fees, more information for those interested can be found here.

As part of my research, I used qualitative research with elite contributors, interviewing industry professionals. These contributors included comedians, TV and radio producers, editors, political advisers and Lord Michael Grade (who was the Chair of OFCOM at the time). The aim was to understand the thought processes when those in editorial control removed challenging programme content, or if writers self-censored because of concerns of being “cancelled”. In short, I wanted to find out who and why broadcast professionals decided to keep in or edit out material that might offend some of their audience members. What were those decisions based on, the law, regulation, or a fear of cancel culture caused by an audience backlash?

Once the PhD was completed there was an open call from Hart publishing to discuss options of turning a PhD into a monograph. I arranged a meeting with Roberta Bass who became my editor (I love saying “my editor”). She sent me the Bloomsbury Academic Proposal Form, I filled this in and submitted a sample chapter. This went out to two reviewers who sent back comments, the comments from Reviewer Two were very much on brand. I had to tweak it, rewrite it and resubmit for further review. This resubmission was sent out to three reviewers, one of which wasn’t at all keen, luckily for me Roberta still pitched my book, and it was accepted for publication.

As my PhD was funded by Southeastern Network for Social Sciences my editor suggested that I should publish the book Open Access. This meant that it could be published as a hard copy but also downloaded from the internet for free and the publishing process is funded by UK Research and Innovation. I agreed, as I suspected that I was not going to get rich from academic sales, after all The Law, Society, and Politics of Entertainment in Britain: Regulation or Self-Censorship was not going to outsell Harry Potter.

Rewriting was an enjoyable process. I was able to put back sections which I had edited out of my PhD and at the same time hone my writing skills. On returning my draft the copy editor commented, “I really enjoyed reading this - I usually work on fairly dry law and tax titles, this was a lot more interesting! So, thank you.” Which, whilst qualified, was an excellent review in my opinion.

I hope you consider reading the book, after all it’s more interesting than fairly dry tax law. Shane Allen, the Former Controller of Comedy Commissioning at the BBC was one of my contributors too and described the book as, “terrific, so many terrific names and interesting perspectives. It’s a masterpiece…”. He has an excellent sense of humour.

Hart says, “This book is essential reading for people keen to understand the editorial process and the effects of 'cancel culture'. It can be bought online or downloaded for free open access.” You can get it here Bloomsbury Collections - The Law, Society, and Politics of Entertainment in Britain


How to turn your passion into a PhD and then get that published │ by Jennifer Young