Some soldiers attitudes to wars in the C20th
This is another example of the use of ICT to access a
collection of sources that has been put together by someone else, saving the
teacher the not inconsiderable time involved in reading through and selecting a
selection of sources/quotes for themselves. The following sources are taken
from a newspaper article based on Joanna Bourke's book, An intimate history
of killing. Drawing on sources from wars across the length of the C20th,
the sources demonstrate that some soldiers have positive feelings about
actively being involved in killing 'a legitimately defined enemy'.
In Bourke's words, 'The possibility of having to
kill, combined with the risk of having to die for their country, is a heady
mixture. Their leaders have spoken in grave terms about the grim duty that
faces them, but behind the sober mask of political and military responsibility
lurks a dark secret: war can be fun.
The sources could be given out to pupils so that they
can be cross-referenced and discussed. The point can also be made that this
'collection' is not a random one; someone has selected these sources to
make a particular point. This collection of sources could be counterpoised
against another selection which presents a very different portait of soldiers'
attitudes to war. (For instance, Robert Graves' Goodbye to all
that.
After discussing and sharing the quotes, the article
as a whole could be given to pupils as a homework (perhaps optional, for anyone
interested). Careful reading of the article would provide pupils with a list of
reasons which help to explain whypeople had such attitudes to killing,
and why these attitudes may have changed as the nature of war evolved over the
course of the century. I haven't got the date of the article to hand, but it
should be traceable by searching the Guardian Newspaper archive for the past
2-3 years.
'The change to come... real business
with real Germans in front of us. Oh I do hope I shall visibly kill a
few.' |
Alfred Bland, British soldier writing
home in 1916 |
'The deep shame I feel is my own lack
of emotional reaction. I keep reacting as though I were simply watching a movie
of the whole thing. I still don't feel that I have personally killed anyone...
Have I become so insensitive that I have to see torn limbs, the bloody ground,
the stinking holes and guts in the mud, before I feel ashamed that I have
destroyed large numbers of my own kind?' |
Diary entry of U.S. pilot in Vietnam
War, 1966, who 'knew his bombs were killing hundreds of civilians each
raid'. |
'Why should women always be asked to
be the cooks? I want to go overseas and take my part with the
men.' |
June Buckley, British woman, World
War 2. |
'No threat was too great; I would
have gone through any threat, for the opportunity to put iron on Saddam
Hussain's head.' |
U.S. pilot, 1st (?) Gulf
War. |
'We'lll never walk, or make love, or
be loved the way we walked and loved and were loved over there. Everything was
heightened by the closeness of death; death hovered everywhere and all the
time.' |
Soviet artillery captain in
Russo-Afghan War 1979-89. |
'When Tony Blair delivered his
morale-boosting speech to British troops preparing for war in the Oman desert,
a corporal standing behind him was wearing a T-shirt with a picture of Saddam
Hussain being booted and the words "We came, we saw, we kicked ass'. Combatants
spoke repeatedly about the atavistic joy of finally being able to throw
themselves into the fray.' |
British soldiers preparing for the
1st Gulf War. Quoted from the Bourne article. |
'Combat soldiers have something that
we haven't got. Realism, discipline, masculinity (kind of a dirty word these
days), resilience, tenacity, resourcefulness. We may have turned out to be
better dancers, choreographers and painters.. but I'm not at all sure that they
didn't turn out to be better man, in the best sense of the
word.' |
Michael Blumenthal, U.S. poet at the
time of the Vietnam War. |
'It's frightening and unpleasant to
have to kill, you think, but you soon realise that what you really find
objectionable is shooting someone point-blank. Killing en masse in a group is
exciting- and I've seen this myself- fun.' |
Soviet soldier, Russo-Afghan War,
1979-89. |
'I knew that war was terrible, but I
was drawn to it, like a moth to a flame.' |
Captain Richard Crandall, British
soldier. |
'I never worried about killing when I
was on the guns: I wasn't actually killing the Germans, I was killing those
that were flying with their bombs. I thought that was good. I really felt
that.' |
Joyce Carr, British anti-aircraft
gunner, World War 2. |
'I feel that everyone has a little
"Rambo Box" in his heart and and he always wonders how well he will react when
it comes to facing an enemy or going against someone who is trying to kill him.
Well, to a man, everyone opened their Rambo Box, found out that there was quite
a bit of energy, quite a bit of courage there, and they all came out of this a
better man for it.' |
Lt. Col. Ted Herman, U.S. Army,
speaking about combat during the Gulf War. |
'It's just like a football game once
you get airborne, you get the jet under you and you start feeling good, then
you just start working- working your game plan.' |
U.S. pilot, Gulf War. |
''The moment the Stealth pilots
landed, they would rush to the nearest television to watch CNN footage. "We'd
huddle around and grab each other and say, hey, that's my target, or wow, look
at that one go, according to one pilot... The warplanes of the USS Enterprise
had hardly landed before the ship's commanding offiecer could be heard
enthusing "Come and see the films". "I feel very proud" a B-52 pilot said a few
days ago, "It's like being a football player in the
Superbowl."' |
U.S. soldiers, Gulf War, quoted in
the Bourke article. |
'My breed, the pilots whose war has
been more chivalrous and clean-handed than any other will (in the future) be
ordered to do violence to the civilian population. We shall drop the gas bombs
and poison the reservoirs. We shall kill the women and children. Of course the
thing is insane; but then, if the world submits to the rule of homicidal
maniacs, it deserves to be destroyed.' |
Cecil Lewis, British pilot, World War
One. |
'British airmen interviewed during
the Second World War expressed "eager-beaver" reactions prior to going
overseas. They were so wrought up that men who were prevented at the last
moment from embarking burst into tears.' |
Quoted in the Bourke
article. |
Back to
ICT
Back to History
PGCE
|