Study examines consequences of workplace bullying

Published by  News Archive

On 17th May 2019

New research reveals how frequently being the target of workplace bullying not only leads to health-related problems but can also cause victims to behave badly themselves.

The study, led by the University of East Anglia (UEA) in collaboration with Uninettuno Telematic International University in Italy, found that in some cases this is characterised by a lack of problem solving and high avoidance coping strategies. For example, drinking alcohol when having a problem, experiencing very frequent negative emotions, such as anger, fear and sadness, and high work ‘moral disengagement’, which refers to the way individuals rationalise their actions and absolve themselves of responsibility for the consequences.

Bullying is one of the major occupational stresses for employees and the effects can compromise their development and health, as well as interfere with the achievement of both personal and professional goals.

It is usually differentiated as work-related and personal-related bullying. The former refers to bullying affecting workload - for example removing responsibility - and work processes, such as attacks on someone’s professional status. The latter refers to both indirect - for example exclusion and isolation - and direct negative behaviour, such as physical abuse.

While previous research has shown a link between being the target of bullying and behavioral problems, for the first time this study identified different configurations of victims by considering not only exposure to and types of bullying, but also health problems and bad behaviour. The study also examined how these groups differ in terms of negative emotions experienced in relation to work, coping strategies, and moral disengagement.

Published in the journal Personality and Individual Differences, the study was led by Dr Roberta Fida, a senior lecturer in work psychology at UEA’s Norwich Business School. She said: “Overall, our results show the need to consider not only exposure to and types of bullying but also their associated consequences. In particular, the findings highlight that victimisation is associated not only with health problems but also with a greater likelihood of not behaving in line with the expected social and organisational norms.

“The greater the intensity of bullying and the more the exposure to different types of bullying, the higher the likelihood of engaging in counterproductive workplace behaviour. Furthermore, the results show that health-related symptoms are not always associated with experiences of bullying. Indeed, while those experiencing limited work-related bullying did not report health problems, those who were not bullied but misbehaved did.”

The authors say the importance of emotions needs to be considered in HR and management intervention policies. “Despite the evidence recognising the relevance of emotions when dealing with workplace aggression, this is rarely incorporated into guidelines,” said Dr Fida. “In addition, it is essential to also promote behavioural regulation strategies to reduce moral disengagement, as well as negative compensating behaviour, such as drinking more alcohol and taking more risks. Its role in allowing ‘otherwise good’ people to freely engage in conduct they would generally consider wrong is further confirmed in this study.”

The researchers asked 1019 Italian employees about their experiences of workplace bullying, counterproductive behaviour and health symptoms. They were also asked about their coping strategies, negative emotions experienced at work and moral disengagement.

Five groups were identified, one of which includes victims who are the target of work-related bullying and frequently exposed to personal-related bullying, who experience high health problems and misbehaviour (4.4% of the sample).

Another group experience work-related bullying but less frequent personal-related bullying, and show lower health problems and misbehaviour (9.6%). Although they generally use problem-solving strategies, they tend to be overwhelmed by the negative emotions they experience and are not able to control them. They also have a tendency to morally disengage.

A third group have limited exposure to work-related bullying and no exposure to personal-related bullying (22.3%). While not experiencing health-related problems they sometimes engage in counterproductive work behaviour.

A fourth group includes those who are not bullied, but have high health-related symptoms and some misbehaviour (23.9%). The last group identified are not exposed to any bullying, have no health symptoms or behavioral problems (39.9%).

Examination of the groups in relation to individual dimensions highlighted the pivotal role of negative emotions and emotional regulation, independently from exposure to workplace bullying. In more severe cases, moral disengagement and compensatory behaviour play an equally important role, suggesting the weakening of individuals’ ability to regulate their behaviour.

Phenomenological Configurations of Workplace Bullying: a cluster Approach’, Marinella Paciello, Roberta Fida, Carlo Tramontano, Valerio Ghezzi, Claudio Barbaranelli, is published in Personality and Individual Differences.

Latest News

 
A male nurse slumped against a wall.
06 Dec 2022

Care home nurses still need support to recover from Covid trauma, research shows

Those on the front line of the Covid pandemic need mental health support to help them recover from, or manage, the stress and trauma they faced - according to...

Read more >
 
Peter Hemmins with robot
01 Nov 2022

Productivity East hosts Robot Wars

Productivity East is usually home to UEA’s engineering students, but on 5 November it played host to almost 100 robots and their creators in the RobotWars...

Read more >
 
image of the brain
01 Dec 2022

University study to support families after Traumatic Brain Injury 

UEA is one of four universities to receive £140,000 funding to conduct a study to determine whether storytelling can support the wellbeing and adjustment of...

Read more >
 
Hanna Thomas Uose
30 Nov 2022

UEA creative writing student wins national writers prize for unpublished novel

Hanna Thomas Uose, who is studying for an MA in Prose Fiction at the University, has won the Morley Prize for Unpublished Writers of Colour 2022. 

Read more >
Are you searching for something?
 
Hanna Thomas Uose
30 Nov 2022

UEA creative writing student wins national writers prize for unpublished novel

Hanna Thomas Uose, who is studying for an MA in Prose Fiction at the University, has won the Morley Prize for Unpublished Writers of Colour 2022. 

Read more >
 
An overweight woman in a doctor's office.
30 Nov 2022

Overweight women most likely to suffer long Covid

Overweight women are more likely to experience symptoms of long Covid according to new research from the University of East Anglia.

Read more >
 
Two panels of the climate change mural artwork
25 Nov 2022

Climate change mural now on display at Norwich City Hall in historic year for Climatic Research Unit

On the 50th anniversary year of UEA’s Climatic Research Unit (CRU), the stark impact of climate change has been brought into focus by a giant mural now on...

Read more >
 
HSJ Awards logo
05 Dec 2022

UEA’s contribution to Clinical Associate in Psychology training shortlisted for national award

UEA, alongside the University of Plymouth and partners, has been shortlisted for two awards at the 2023 Health Service Journal (HSJ) Partnership Awards.

Read more >
 
Chemical molecules
01 Nov 2022

UEA researchers uncover how ancient protein-bound iron cofactors are assembled in bacteria

Mass spectrometric studies of the assembly of an essential and common iron- and sulfur-containing cofactor has revealed a ‘sulfur first’ mechanism.

Read more >
 
01 Nov 2022

Dec 22 issue of UEA Chemistry Magazine is out now

The December 2022 edition of our UEA Chemistry Magazine: yoUr chEm mAg is now available.

Read more >