Independent music squashed out of streaming playlists and revenue

Published by  Communications

On 2nd Mar 2021

Bands and artists on independent record labels get less than their fair share of access to the most popular playlists on streaming platforms such as Spotify – argues a new paper from the University of East Anglia.

The paper, published today, looks at whether streaming platforms offer a level playing field for artists and record labels.

It finds that major labels have an unfair advantage when it comes to playlist access – and that they take the lion’s share of subscription revenue as a result.

As a possible remedy, the research team suggests changing the payment system, so that royalties generated by individual listener subscriptions go direct to the labels, bands and artists they are listening to.

They also recommend more transparency in how playlists are created and how the algorithms behind music recommendations work.

Finally, they recommend greater transparency about contracts and say that major labels with financial stakes in streaming platforms should be forced to divest.

Not overhauling the system, they say, is likely stifle innovation and creativity in the long run - which will in turn impact both the industry and consumers.

Prof Peter Ormosi, from UEA’s Norwich Business School and Centre for Competition Policy, said: “Music streaming has become the most important route to market recorded music, and this position is likely to strengthen in future.

“Music streaming platforms like Spotify pay the labels royalties that are calculated on a pro rata basis, as a proportion of the revenues associated with the streams of their content.

“We wanted to see how streaming platforms support or distort fair competition between different types of recorded music and their creators – whether they offer a level playing field for artists and labels.

“A level playing field is important not only for artists but also, over the longer term, for consumers. If competition is distorted it risks inhibiting innovation, variety and the prospects of upcoming and more niche artists.

“Creativity and innovation are vital for the music industry - if streaming platforms stifle this, it will be bad for the whole industry and consumers in the long run.”

The team studied in detail how streaming platforms such as Spotify and Apple Music operate – including how streaming revenues are split between major and independent labels and artists, the role of playlists, and how some major labels also hold shares in streaming platforms.

Co-author Prof Amelia Fletcher, also from UEA’s Norwich Business School and Centre for Competition Policy, said: “Playlists on music streaming platforms play a central role in disseminating music to consumers. As such, it is important for ensuring fair competition that independent artists have fair access to playlists.

“But our research suggests that independent label artists are getting less than their fair share of access to the most popular playlists.

“While the vast majority of playlists are curated by Spotify, the shares of the major labels’ own proprietary playlists may exacerbate the situation.

“This disproportionately lesser access is likely to have a direct impact on revenues for independent labels and their artists as well as an indirect impact on the sustainability of this important segment of the market in the future.

Co-author Daniel Antal, founder of Reprex, a big data startup focusing on the music industry, said: “The impact of playlists on royalty payments is likely to be accentuated under a pro-rata royalty allocation system.

“We recommend that the payment system should be reformed by moving from the pro-rata payment system to a user-centric remuneration, where the royalties generated by an individual user’s subscription is simply split between what they choose to listen to.

“We would also encourage greater transparency of contracts, once they are agreed, to help ensure fair treatment, or alternatively that competition authorities should allow industry-wide negotiation by labels, as is already carried out for performance and mechanical royalties on the composition side of the split.

“Finally, we note that some of the majors have residual equity stakes in Spotify. For example Universal holds a 3.5 per cent stake and Sony Music a 2.9 per cent stake, in Spotify. And Deezer is part-owned by Access Industries which in turn owns Warner Music Group.

“Requiring divestment of such stakes could also be helpful in ensuring that streaming platforms have the right incentives to ensure a level playing field.”

Music streaming: is it a level playing field?’ is published in the journal Competition Policy International

Study with us

Explore our research

Latest News

  News
Adult holding a child's hands
03 Dec 2021

Making the right decisions for children growing up in long-term foster care

Read more >
  News
Young women volunteering at a food donation centre
02 Dec 2021

UEA volunteer research reveals how to build inclusive societies

Strong partnerships between volunteers and their governments are key to how we build equal and inclusive societies – according to a new UN report involving UEA...

Read more >
  News
Female Barista Giving Parcel And Coffee To Customer
02 Dec 2021

New support launched for employers and staff affected by Covid-19 pandemic

A new resource has been launched to help employers and frontline workers as they recover from the impacts of Covid-19.

Read more >
  News
Blue and white pills falling onto a flat surface.
01 Dec 2021

The diabetes medication that could revolutionise heart failure treatment

A medication originally used for patients with diabetes is the first to help people with heart failure and could revolutionise treatment, according to new UEA...

Read more >
Are you searching for something?
  News
Blue and white pills falling onto a flat surface.
01 Dec 2021

The diabetes medication that could revolutionise heart failure treatment

A medication originally used for patients with diabetes is the first to help people with heart failure and could revolutionise treatment, according to new UEA...

Read more >
  News
A phone on a table with the reflection of a palm tree on it
30 Nov 2021

Locking your phone in a box can help you break free

Going cold turkey without your phone on holiday may be the key to healthier digital wellbeing, a new study from the University of East Anglia and the University...

Read more >
  News
Letters on wooden blocks spelling out the word dementia
26 Nov 2021

De-cluttering may not help people with dementia

A clutter-free environment may not help people with dementia carry out daily tasks – according to a new UEA study.

Read more >
  News
Two fruit flies facing each other on a stick of celery.
24 Nov 2021

How eating less in early life could help with reproduction later on

Switching from a restricted diet to eating as much as you like could be beneficial for reproduction in later life, according to new UEA research.

Read more >
  News
A jaguar in the Pantanal, South America
23 Nov 2021

Wildlife conservation and economically viable land use are compatible

Wildlife conservation on land that is also economically viable is possible, according to a new study involving the University of East Anglia.

Read more >
  News
02 Nov 2021

Read November issue of yoUr chEm mAg

The November edition of UEA's Chemistry Magazine is now available.

Read more >
  News
Fields in Colombia
30 Nov 2021

All systems GROW for UEA's Colombian project

This month saw the largest and most important summit of 2021, COP26. UEA made its presence felt in a number of ways, including showcasing the results of their...

Read more >